Hardie (35900km):
1224 days ago Liptons fantastic conditions and great sailing
Was a bit disappointed with my alpha of 23.2 thought I'd done my best alpha for years, just checked with KA72 and got a 24.649, I'll send my file
Edit 23/11 = Have been informed by a member of the technical committee that Speedreader uses much stricter data criteria than KA72 to screen out data error, so I'll leave it as it is. However, I may start using KA72 again though, as that alpha did not feel like a 23kt alpha, I'm experienced enough to gauge the speed of alphas, and I was expecting to see 25kts+alpha because it felt that fast. The KA72 alpha of 24.649 was much closer to how it felt and having spent many years doing alphas in the 24/25/26kt range I think I can trust my experience.
Mike here, exercising captains perogative.
Joe's file had very bad data during the gybe, because he wears the GT31 on his chest. Leaning into the gybe obscures a lot of satellites directly but gives the unit a clear view of reflections from the water. This caused the +/- values to go over 2knots. Speedreader changes these numbers to 0, resulting in a lower alpha.

KA72 seems to ignore accuracy numbers altogether, allowing some less than optimum results through.
Personally I think reducing these numbers to 0 maybe a tad harsh, so I've done a recalculation, with the offending numbers reduced by their +/- numbers. That comes out as an even 24, so I'm quite happy to see that.
But the take away lesson here is, don't wear your unit low on your shoulder!!!!
And just for comparison, here's my alpha gybe, with my DIY unit on top of my head

And here's a GW60 on my wrist.

the unit on my head doesn't change at all, and the GW60 does change going from over to under arm, but not enough to trigger filters.
|